Ford Truck Club Forum

Ford Truck Club Forum (http://www.fordtruckclub.net/forum/index.php)
-   Garage Talk: Paint & Detailing (http://www.fordtruckclub.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=75)
-   -   Useless Fuel in Drive (http://www.fordtruckclub.net/forum/showthread.php?t=3500)

JSoko July 11th, 2010 09:22 AM

Useless Fuel in Drive
 
I was at the local watering hole last nite, and got into a disscussion about how in NASCAR the drivers will coast, with either the clutch in or shift to neutral to save gas. And Big Mike said he does that all the time when driving his Truck (auto trans) in traffic and shifts to neutral when at a stop. Well in comes Keven Thompsom (mister know-it-all, and ace mechanic) and after a few drinks and some time later it was found, and agreed upon that Big Mike is actualy useing more gas. Bottom line is, it's not necessary to put an automatic in neutral while sitting at a traffic light. Leaving it in Drive will use less fuel.
Here is Keven Thompsons take " the injectors are shut down completely when coasting in gear, while ideling in neutral still consumes fuel"
Where do I go from here??

comments and suggestions welcomed.

Klitch July 11th, 2010 08:16 PM

I've always heard, and agreed that when coasting with an automatic in gear is more efficient than neutral. always heard the injectors shut off, and watching my wideband I have to agree when it shows full lean numbers (maxing out on air)

nine5flareside July 11th, 2010 09:06 PM

So for those with automatic vehicles, it is more fuel efficient to leave the car in gear when stopped at a light rather than put the vehicle in nuetral. To be honest, I never really thought about putting my truck into nuetral when stopped at a light in order to save on fuel.

I use 91 octane, sometimes 93 so any type of deal on gas for me went out the window at that point, not to mention I now have a cam and engine that just love gas more than I do!

Very good post for those who try to conserve their fuel and not burn it right away.

JSoko July 11th, 2010 09:23 PM

I shifted to neutral when ideling for any period of time not for fuel savings, but thinking Iam saving the torque converter/ trans
as the RPM's do rise

especially when I had the built '77 F100
but then again it sure did clunk hard when I went to D

on my other Trucks they will for now on out stay in D

heck whats twenty cents

Klitch July 11th, 2010 10:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jsoko (Post 33151)
heck whats twenty cents

In some cases, an overdraft fee.

BigT67 July 12th, 2010 02:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jsoko (Post 33151)
I shifted to neutral when ideling for any period of time not for fuel savings, but thinking Iam saving the torque converter/ trans
as the RPM's do rise

especially when I had the built '77 F100
but then again it sure did clunk hard when I went to D

on my other Trucks they will for now on out stay in D

heck whats twenty cents

2 dimes

whitesleeper February 15th, 2011 12:24 AM

leave in or out of gear ????
 
ok at a stop light leave it in gear 20 cents - 2 dims - 1 cup of gas that aint didly . HOWEVER CHECK FOR YOUR YEAR AND MODEL OF TRANS TO SEE IF IT STILL PUMPS IN NEUTRAL OR PARK AND IF IT DOES AND YOU END UP SETTING FOR A WHILE TAKE IT OUT OF DRIVE .... ok the reason simple IF you run over sized tires have a OLD clutch fan or a ELEC fan a engine thats been bored . the trans can and WILL get hot .. most tranny have the cooler built into the rad which runs around 180-200 death to a trans STARTS at 220ish .. Install a trans temp guage YOU will be amazed how much it can change and how fast it will do it .... in 9 seconds i would go from 100 to 230 and i had a 16 row ext cooler with its own fan . That only happened when i was doing truck pulls . My moto the more i know about what my truck is doing the more i can save in repairs down the road i dont know about others out and about BUT my money tree isnt growing that much 3.19 pr gallon of gas!!

Russo2 February 15th, 2011 02:31 AM

Old thread buuuuttttt. I have never heard of the injectors shutting down or any of that stuff, I don't deal with slughboxes I just push in the clutch at a red light :D
However I have heard that it is not good for an automatic transmission to coast in neutral, don't know why just what I heard. And doesn't an auto idle pretty low even in gear?
And if you are going through the trouble to put it in neutral, why not park? Only a little further and then you don't have to hold the brake.

DoubleDee February 27th, 2013 02:57 PM

x2 on old thread.. was brought here by seeing it in the "Similar Threads" box below. Regardless... The only time I shift to N at a stop light is if it's a long cycle. Save your tranny! I agree with what whitesleeper says above. You can possibly overheat the tranny if you leave it in gear to long without moving. I haven't witnessed this with my 2 trucks (I don't have a tranny temp gauge and desire one badly), but I have with my tanker.

Granted, it's a military vehicle, I've accidentally left one in drive with the park brakes on for a few minutes, luckily, I came back to the cab to check on something, realized it was still in drive, placed it in neutral and noticed the tranny temp was up in the 220'ish range. Oops.

Back to our trucks. Also, another reason I'll put it in N or maybe P, is if I've braked to hard. Get them hot pads off that hot rotor and some air space between. I don't want to warp them anymore than they already are. Yeah, the distance between pad and rotor isn't much when not applied, but it's something. You might scoff at my reasoning, but, I am entitled to my own opinion damint. :kool:

The Frankster March 26th, 2013 01:20 PM

Maybe old, but some good tips. I would think any pressure off those rotors would be benificial. I'll have to remind myself that when I get those slotted and drilled on.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:32 PM.



FordTruckClub.net is not authorized, endorsed or affiliated with the Ford Motor Company
or any of their subsidiaries. FordŽ is a registered trademark of the Ford Motor Company


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6 Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.